How to Teach a Dog to Use a Puzzle Toy
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Many dogs ignore a new puzzle toy, paw at it once and walk away, or get frustrated and start chewing it. That does not mean puzzles are not for them. Dogs have to learn how a puzzle works, and most learn fast if you start easy and raise the difficulty slowly. This guide shows how to teach a dog to use a puzzle toy, step by step.
How we wrote this: the steps come from Best Friends Animal Society’s guides to using food puzzles and toys that keep dogs busy, Battersea’s brain games for dogs, and Dogs Trust’s guides to enrichment activities and resource guarding. All were checked on 1 November 2026. We did not test any puzzle toys for this guide, and we do not show prices or ratings.
Why dogs need to be taught
Best Friends makes the key point: animals are not born knowing how to forage from a puzzle. In the wild, family members teach them; at home, that job is ours. Most dogs need to start with a simple puzzle and work up to harder ones as they gain skill.
Best Friends also notes that dogs learn at different speeds, so a friend’s dog solving an advanced puzzle on day one tells you nothing about yours. Battersea adds a practical warning: if a puzzle is too hard, a dog may lose interest and give up. The whole method below is about keeping your dog winning.
What you need
- An easy first puzzle. A toy that releases its reward with almost no effort. A rubber stuffable toy such as the KONG Classic (or the KONG Puppy for young dogs) is a common first step, because loosely filled it gives up its contents when nudged. A PAW5 Wooly Snuffle Mat is another easy start, since it uses the dog’s nose rather than problem solving.
- A harder puzzle for later. Sliding or spinning puzzles, such as the Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Dog Tornado, ask the dog to move parts in a set way. Save these until your dog is confident with the easy ones.
- Small rewards your dog loves. What goes inside is up to you and your vet; for ideas, see inthekibble.com.
- A quiet spot with an easy-clean floor. Battersea suggests a hard, easy-to-clean surface for messy games.
Our best puzzle toys for dogs and best snuffle mat for dogs guides compare the options by type and size.
Step 1: make the first puzzle almost too easy
Battersea says to start at an easy level, and with stuffable toys to begin with a filling that falls out fairly easily. In practice:
- Put the reward where your dog can see or smell it: in an open compartment, on the surface of the mat, or loosely inside the toy.
- Set the toy down and let your dog investigate. Do not point at it, push it toward them or move their paws for them.
- The moment your dog gets a reward out, praise them. The first win is the lesson: this object pays.
- Keep the first session short, a few minutes at most, and stop while your dog is still keen.
If your dog shows no interest, Best Friends suggests trying a reward they find more exciting before you decide the puzzle is the problem. Once your dog understands what a puzzle is and enjoys it, you can move to less exciting rewards.
Step 2: help a little, then step back
Battersea says you may need to show your dog what to do if they are struggling with a puzzle feeder. Keep your help small:
- Nudge a lid open or slide a piece halfway, so the next move is obvious.
- Drop a reward right next to the part your dog should touch.
- Mark and reward any try at the right movement, even a sniff or a paw touch. If you use a clicker, our how to clicker train a dog guide explains marking.
Help less each session. The goal is a dog who solves the puzzle alone, not one who waits for you.
Step 3: teach the moves the puzzle needs
Some puzzles need skills your dog has never used, such as lifting a cone, pulling a tab or spinning a lid. Battersea suggests teaching skills like picking things up or pulling first if your dog is stuck. You can practice these away from the puzzle with a toy, then bring the skill back. A dog who already knows “take it” or “pull” usually works out a lift-the-lid puzzle quickly.
Step 4: raise the difficulty one notch at a time
Battersea describes making a stuffed toy harder bit by bit: pack it tighter once your dog is getting the contents out easily, and put the tastiest part at the far end so your dog keeps working. The same idea works for any puzzle:
- Fill fewer compartments, or fill the harder ones.
- Close lids that were left open.
- Move from a one-step puzzle to a two-step one, such as the Dog Tornado’s stacked layers.
- For a snuffle mat, tuck rewards deeper into the fabric.
Change one thing at a time. If your dog stalls, gets frustrated or starts chewing the toy instead of solving it, go back to the last level they found easy and stay there a few more sessions.
Step 5: supervise every session
Battersea recommends supervising your dog with any puzzle toy or activity feeder so they do not chew or swallow anything harmful. Best Friends says to watch closely with plastic puzzles in particular, so your dog does not chew the plastic or get their teeth stuck in part of the toy. Dogs Trust gives the same advice for food games, especially homemade ones.
A plastic puzzle is a thinking toy, not a chew toy. For a dog who destroys toys, start with a sturdy rubber toy and see our best dog toys for aggressive chewers guide.
Step 6: put it away when the game is over
When your dog has finished, or walks away, pick the puzzle up. This stops unsupervised chewing, keeps the toy special, and lets you check it for damage. Wash it before next time; our guide on how to clean dog and cat toys covers rubber, plastic and fabric.
Dogs Trust suggests rotating toys weekly to keep dogs interested, and Best Friends recommends swapping a few toys every week or so. Two or three puzzles used in turn hold a dog’s interest longer than one used every day.
Puzzles with more than one dog
Battersea suggests separating dogs during food games so each can take their time without feeling they must compete. If your dog stiffens, guards or growls over a puzzle, Battersea suggests asking an expert before you go on. Dogs Trust explains that guarding is a worried, often fear-based response, not naughtiness, and lists early signs such as standing over the item, a tense body and staring. Do not take the puzzle away by force; give your dog space and get help from a qualified behaviorist.
Other ways to use the same skills
- Snuffle mats and scatter games. Dogs Trust suggests scattering rewards for your dog to sniff out, or laying a trail to follow. These suit dogs who find puzzles hard, and nose games are a good warm-up.
- Lick mats. Dogs Trust mentions lick mats as a calm food game. A mat such as the LickiMat Classic Buddy needs no problem solving; see our best lick mat for dogs and cats guide.
- Cardboard puzzles. Best Friends describes a box with one side cut away, then less and less of the side removed, until the dog can open a closed box. Battersea suggests a box of scrunched paper. Supervise, since cardboard can be swallowed.
When to get help
A dog who gets very frustrated, guards toys, or swallows pieces of toys needs more than a different puzzle. Dogs Trust says dogs that swallow items that are not food, or eat very quickly, are at risk of serious medical problems. If your dog swallows part of a toy, call your vet. For guarding or frustration, ask your vet to rule out pain and then work with a qualified behaviorist.
FAQ
Why won’t my dog play with a puzzle toy?
Usually the puzzle is too hard, or the reward is not exciting enough. Best Friends says dogs are not born knowing how to use puzzles and suggests starting with the easiest one you can find and a reward your dog loves. Some dogs also prefer a different type, such as a snuffle mat.
How long should a dog play with a puzzle toy?
Keep early sessions to a few minutes and stop while your dog is still interested. Longer sessions come with skill. Always supervise and put the puzzle away afterward.
Are puzzle toys good for puppies?
Yes, if they are easy and the right size. Start with a soft rubber puppy toy or a snuffle mat, supervise closely, and keep sessions short. Our best chew toys for teething puppies guide covers puppy-safe materials.
Can I leave my dog alone with a puzzle toy?
Battersea and Best Friends both say to supervise, because dogs can chew or swallow parts. Leave your dog only with toys made for unsupervised chewing, and only once you know how they treat them.